Thursday, November 13, 2014

Proving old claims

After reading a post I had made at the beginning of the term, I noticed that I had made a promise to prove or disprove an every-day claim using mathematical logic learnt during all these weeks in this course.

The claim I have chosen to prove is "Someone who doesn't eat meat can survive."

Let's say...
  • H(x): the set of all Humans.
  • M(x): the set of Meat-eaters.
  • V(x): the set of Survivors.
Claim:  \exists \!\, x \in \!\, H, ¬ M(x)  V(x)

Let x = Jinny                    # Jinny is my friend who is a vegan
   Then x \in \!\, H                   # She's also human
        Then ¬ M(x)            # She doesn't eat meat
        But len(x) this year > len(x) last year  # She is taller now
        Then x grows          # There must be something else that gives her protein  
        Then x finds another food source  # She doesn't starve!
        Then x eats
        Then x breathes  # She can't move mouth muscles to chew without respiration; Oxygen in! 
        Then x has energy  # From the law stating that Respiration = Energy + CO2 + H20
        Then x can move    # Einstein's Law of Conservation of  Energy; it has to go somewhere!
        Then x can run away from danger  # Energy well-used, Jinny
        Then x can survive                         # Gloria Gaynor
        Then V(x)        
        Then ¬ M(x)  V(x)           
Then \exists \!\, x \in \!\, H, ¬ M(x)  V(x)   And, proven! You can indeed survive if you don't eat meat.



* As a side-note, I really enjoyed reading the post "Week 10 (Problem Solving)" by http://bgancsc165.blogspot.ca/ who eloquently explains how to prove that 5n^4 - 3n^2 + 1 is in
O(6n^5 - 4n^2 + 2n ). This was a tutorial question that I personally did not know how to solve until I read the post.  Highly recommended!

No comments:

Post a Comment